Suggest Thiollier or Hornsent: Elden Ring Quest Guide!

In Shadow of the Erdtree, players are often faced with pivotal decisions that can shape their journey. 

One such decision involves choosing between Thiollier and Hornsent. Both characters present unique opportunities and challenges, but deciding between them isn’t as straightforward as it might seem. 

If you’re wondering Suggest Thiollier or Hornsent for your questline, this guide will help you understand the impact of each choice and guide you towards making an informed decision.

Understanding Suggest Thiollier or Hornsent in Shadow of the Erdtree

In the vast world of Elden Ring’s DLC expansion, Shadow of the Erdtree, the Needle Knight Leda asks you to choose between two figures: Thiollier and Hornsent. 

This decision plays a crucial role in shaping your questline, leading to different outcomes, quests, and potential alliances. Here’s a deeper look at what each option entails:

What Happens When You Suggest Thiollier?

Thiollier is a follower of St. Trina, a figure known for peaceful guidance. His demeanor is calm, and his intentions appear pure. 

Suggesting Thiollier may seem like the safer, morally correct option, but it comes with its own set of consequences.

Peaceful Approach

Thiollier often represents calm and devotion. When you choose him, Leda perceives him as harmless, dismissing him as a non-threat.

Minimal Conflict

Choosing Thiollier leads to a more passive outcome, avoiding any direct confrontation. However, this path might not offer much excitement or deeper story progression.

Best for Peace-Seeking Players

If you prefer an experience focused on tranquility and moral alignment, Thiollier is likely the better option for you.

What Happens When You Suggest Hornsent?

Hornsent, on the other hand, is a far more complex figure. He harbors dark intentions and is driven by vengeance. 

Suggesting Hornsent leads to more dramatic consequences, including action, conflict, and moral dilemmas.

High Stakes 

Hornsent is seen as a threat by Leda. Choosing him sets off a series of events where she plans to deal with him.

Unpredictable Outcomes

Suggesting Hornsent is likely to take you on a much more adventurous and challenging path, filled with danger and intense encounters.

Best for Players Seeking Action and Drama

If you want a questline that’s rich in conflict, moral ambiguity, and action-packed storytelling, Hornsent will offer that thrill.

How to Decide Between Thiollier and Hornsent?

Factors to Consider

Before making your choice, it’s essential to evaluate the impact each option has on your overall gameplay and narrative experience. Here are a few key points to consider:

• Playstyle:
  • If you lean towards peaceful, methodical gameplay, Thiollier may be the better fit.
  • If you enjoy dramatic storylines with high stakes and intense action, Hornsent offers that excitement.
• Character Development:
  • Choosing Thiollier emphasizes character development with a focus on spirituality and devotion.
  • Hornsent dives deeper into the complexities of revenge, giving you the chance to explore morally gray areas.
• Questline Divergence:
  • Thiollier’s questline may loop back to a quieter resolution.
  • Hornsent’s storyline is more engaging, branching into long-term consequences and dramatic events.

What Do Players Recommend?

Reddit Discussions and Community Advice

Reddit, a key platform for Elden Ring players, has numerous discussions on this topic, making it easier to gauge what the community thinks about these choices:

• Suggest Thiollier or Hornsent Reddit discussions indicate that players tend to lean towards Hornsent if they want a deeper, more action-packed storyline.
• Suggest Thiollier or Hornsent Elden Ring discussions also reveal that Hornsent provides a more dynamic questline with serious challenges, while Thiollier sticks to a simpler, more peaceful path.

Which Option Should You Choose?

Consider Your Goals and Playstyle

The choice between Thiollier and Hornsent largely depends on what kind of experience you’re looking for:

• Choose Thiollier if you prefer a peaceful, straightforward path with minimal conflict and more spiritual depth.
• Choose Hornsent if you enjoy dramatic storylines, action-packed adventures, and morally complex choices that impact the game’s progression.

Conclusion

Ultimately, suggest Thiollier or Hornsent in Shadow of the Erdtree will shape your journey in Elden Ring’s expansive world. 

Depending on your gameplay style and the story experience you crave, each decision offers a unique adventure. 

Whether you want to tread peacefully or dive into action, the choice is yours. Consider your options carefully, as it will lead you down two very different paths.

FAQs

What happens if I suggest Thiollier to Leda?

If you suggest Thiollier, Leda dismisses him as harmless, leading to a peaceful resolution with little to no conflict.

What happens if I suggest Hornsent to Leda?

Suggesting Hornsent prompts Leda to see him as a threat, triggering more dynamic events, action, and potentially greater narrative developments.

Which is the better choice for action and excitement?

Hornsent is the better choice if you’re looking for action-packed encounters, high-stakes decisions, and an engaging storyline with more drama.

Is there a Reddit thread discussing Thiollier vs. Hornsent?

Yes, many Reddit threads cover this debate. Search for Suggest Thiollier or Hornsent Reddit to read detailed player opinions and gameplay tips.

What are the long-term consequences of choosing Hornsent?

Choosing Hornsent can lead to deeper storyline branching, with more intense battles, morally ambiguous decisions, and dramatic developments. This path often results in confrontations and changes to the game’s progression, making it ideal for those seeking complex, action-packed gameplay.

Will suggesting Thiollier impact future alliances or NPC interactions?

Suggesting Thiollier may not significantly impact future alliances or NPC interactions, as Leda perceives him as harmless and a lesser threat. This path is simpler, with fewer branching consequences for NPC relationships.

Can you switch choices between Thiollier and Hornsent once made?

Once you make the choice between Thiollier or Hornsent, it locks your decision into that path. You cannot switch mid-quest. It’s important to choose carefully, as each decision leads to vastly different outcomes.

How do community opinions differ on which to suggest?

Community opinions, found on forums like Reddit, often suggest Hornsent for players seeking an engaging and action-filled experience, while Thiollier is favored by those who prefer a quieter, more spiritually focused questline.